As an independent asset condition reviewer, Elliot Engineering provides engineering review services for Independent System Operators (ISOs) and Regional Transmission Organizations (RTOs).
We offer independent engineering review of electric utility transmission and substation asset condition needs, proposed projects, and alternatives.
What Is an Independent Asset Condition Review?
An independent asset condition review gives ISOs and RTOs an outside engineering assessment of a utility’s proposed replacement project before it moves forward.
Utilities replace aging grid equipment every year. Whether this work is called asset condition projects, proactive replacement, or asset renewal, an independent review takes a closer look at which assets need attention and how soon.
An independent asset condition reviewer examines the proposed project and evaluates whether repair, replacement, or a more targeted approach could meet the need cost-effectively.
How Our Asset Condition Review Works
Our asset condition review follows four steps. It starts with the utility’s own records and ends with a clear recommendation.
- Gather Information. We review the utility’s inspection reports, photos, test results, and maintenance records.
- Assess the Need. We determine whether the evidence supports repair or replacement.
- Evaluate the Options. We review the proposed project to confirm its scope matches the assets in need.
- Share Our Findings. We deliver a clear, evidence-based recommendation to the ISO or RTO.
Elliot Engineering serves in a review role only. We do not design or build the replacement, which keeps our opinion fully independent.
Why ISOs and RTOs Choose Elliot Engineering
ISOs and RTOs need a reviewer who has the technical depth to evaluate utility projects and no role in designing or building them.
- Relevant experience. Elliot Engineering currently provides independent asset condition review services to a large regional transmission organization.
- Licensed expertise. Our Professional Engineers are licensed in multiple states.
- A utility-side perspective. Our team brings extensive utility-side experience, so we understand how these projects are built and justified.
- Broad technical knowledge. We have deep power systems expertise across transmission, distribution, protection and control, and NERC compliance.
Independent Asset Condition Review Support
Elliot Engineering supports independent review in multiple regions. We are available to discuss similar review needs with other ISOs and RTOs.
Source: Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC)
Project Experience
Our asset condition review work covers a range of transmission project types, including:
- Transmission Line Rebuilds: Reviewed structure condition, inspection records, and the case for targeted replacement versus a full rebuild.
- Conductor and Shield-Wire Replacement: Evaluated condition, obsolete materials, repair options, and restoration challenges.
- Underground Cable Replacement: Assessed cable condition, maintenance history, and opportunities to reuse existing civil infrastructure.
- Project Alternatives: Compared proposed scope, phased replacement options, cost estimates, and assumptions about future equipment replacement.
FAQs
Here are answers to common questions about independent asset condition review for ISOs and RTOs.
What is an independent asset condition review?
It is an outside engineering assessment of the need for a proposed utility project and whether the preferred approach is supported by the evidence.
Does an independent review approve the project?
No. We provide technical findings and recommendations that support informed decision-making. Project approvals remain with the responsible organizations.
What types of assets can Elliot Engineering review?
Elliot Engineering reviews transmission lines, underground cables, transformers, circuit breakers, protective relays, and other transmission equipment that a utility has proposed replacing because of its condition.
What information is needed for a review?
A review generally requires inspection reports, photos, test results, maintenance records, and project documents that describe the proposed work and its alternatives.
Does older equipment always need to be replaced?
No. Age is only one consideration. We also examine condition, performance, repair options, and the risks of keeping equipment in service.
Does the review consider alternatives to full replacement?
Yes. Depending on the project, options may include repair, refurbishment, targeted replacement, or completing the work in phases.
Talk to an Engineer About Independent Review
Contact Elliot Engineering to discuss an upcoming asset condition review with one of our engineers.
Specialized Services
Planning & Studies
Design & EPC Offerings
Application & Consulting
Project Management
Testing & Commissioning
Speak with an expert today!
Tell us about your project needs. Whether it’s a big idea or just needing some inspiration, we are here to help. From concept to creation, let us inspire you.
